[1][2]
Review:..
Inside the package we found:
A battery
A charger
An USB data cable
A Bluetooth stereo headset - it¡s still unclear whether the commercial
version will be shipped with the DS-200 or DS-220 model
A wire stereo headset
A 1 Gb Memory Stick Micro (M2) card
A USB adapter for the M2 stuff
A copy of the Media Manager software
A synchro software
A user manual
Design & Ergonomics
The slider form factor was rarely seen among Sony Ericsson products, but
there were a few Walkman phones designed in this way. The first try at
making some sliding stuff was relatively successful - the W850i turned out
fairly all right on the whole, unlike the poor Nokia guys who had a very
hard time trying to piece together a good slider - it has n¡t been until recently that Nokia sliders got up to the
rest of the company ¡s products in terms of quality and ergonomics. Getting
back to the topic, the W910i sports a fine sliding mechanism, the
implementation is close to brilliant. It¡s tight, smooth and only takes a
single push of the finger for the sliding part to go the full way
automatically, so your only options are to have the phone either open or
closed, but no matter how good you are at mishandling sliders, you won ¡t be
able to have the upper part stuck somewhere halfway.
Oh, we just forget to tell you that you can hardly expect to see a fairly
noticeable play between the parts because there¡s none and neither does the
mechanism seem to develop any during usage. But there¡s one nasty little
thing about, the back surface of the upper part has a really bad coating -
not in the sense of looks or feel but just because the fact it gets
scratched by the guide rails in about two weeks. And there¡s nothing you can
do or say to change this. The bottom of the casing acts as the finger rest
for opening the phone. The matte coating resists greasing, so you there¡s no
problem here.
The casing is made from plastic with a few metal pieces added. The back
panel sports a black soft-touch coating. The device is available in two
alternate colors - Hearty Red and Noble Black, which looks like there¡s some
gender segmentation and similar sophisticated terms on the minds of SE¡s
market experts that they hope will increase sales by catering towards people
of both sexes - the women are expected to pick red while men would allegedly
choose black. The overall design looks stylish yet ascetic, the slim (less
than a millimeter) build only adds to the impression. Unlike the less
expensive W580i and S500i, this one shows no signs of any ornamental design
or additional texturing which gives the device a more plain look, yet only
exaggerates its strict lines. This slider really has a bit of the Spartan
spirit about it.
The overall dimensions of the novelty are on an average level save probably
for the unusual slimness. That¡s a good point on the side of ergonomics, the
new Walkman is a pleasure to hold in the hand, though the same can hardly be
said about the keypad. Unlike the W880i and T650i models, the buttons are of
a quite regular type and size, but they just don¡t feel tight enough on
pressing so you can hardly feel if the button was properly pressed or not.
The backlighting is weak and it¡s hard to guess what exact button you¡re
pressing if you¡re in a dark room; though you can easily distinguish between
horizontal rows of buttons, it¡s way harder in the vertical sense, the
buttons are rather poorly separated if we look at each individual column.
Finally, the keypad itself has a rather cheap look as if it were just
wrapped in cellophane ¡V doesn¡t hurt functionality yet spoils the image of
a top-positioned device.
There are no lighting effects save probably for the navigation block
switching from white to orange every time you activate the player mode
(orange seems to be the trademark color of the Walkman series) The wire
headset that¡s shipped along with the phone (HPM-70) doesn¡t sport a high
quality and the Bluetooth one (DS-200) has Play and Stop controls only, this
doesn¡t help the device¡s image much. Sticking to the well-established SE
tradition, the interface slot also serving as the hack for the wire headset
is of the trademark design and placed on the left edge of the phone ¡V
that¡s not the first SE device to follow this principle. By trademark design
we mean that traditional 3,5 mm standard is a no go here, unlike the recent
products by Nokia which came on terms with the widely accepted standard,
putting aside the grotesquely shaped designer slots.
The navigation block has nothing very special about it, but now it comes
with dedicated call buttons which has been rarely seen before among SE
products (until the release of K850i, to be more precise). Besides those,
there¡s also the navigation button with the OK label on it (and acting as
the OK button as well), two touch buttons and the quick buttons with Menu
and Cancel functions bound to them. On the right side the luminance sensor
is found. The video call camera is placed above the screen, the back surface
hosts the main 2 Mpix camera with a phone status indicator nearby. The
bottom edge is completely deserted, and the left one hosts the above
mentioned interface slot. The power and Walkman buttons are positioned at
the top edge, the right edge has the volume control rocker button and a
fully functional M2 slot of course with the hot swap capability and the
single-positioned camera button, like most phones which have cameras without
the auto-focusing capability
Two photo buttons are placed above the screen. The right one calls the
thumbnails, the left one opens the selected photo or clip. Considering the
secondary status of the W910i camera (2 Mpix with no auto-focus capability),
the actual practical advantage that comes with these two buttons is
challengeable in a big way. The player button at the same time is somewhat
less comfortable than one would expect from a purely musical phone, hidden
at the upper edge of the handset along with the power button ¡V fancy some
SE engineers mixing things up end giving a Walkman the controls of a
Cyber-shot. It stands to reason that it would be much better to have the
dedicated player controls placed at a more reachable location while there¡s
no real necessity for any photo buttons with this model. We were really
surprised seeing SE having settled the things in quite the opposite way.
The battery cover sports an improvised lock so it won¡t be gone
accidentally. The SIM card slot has a lot in common with similar slots found
in other SE products, it¡s a bit hard to get the SIM card out, the solution
doesn¡t look like it took a lot of thinking from the engineers¡ part so
here¡s the result. Right in the vicinity of the battery cover lock rests the
protective metal mesh that keeps the speaker out of the harm¡s way. Despite
the fact it¡s placed on the back, the sound doesn ¡t get muffled or
distorted when the phone is lying on a desk or similar flat surface ¡V a
really huge practical improvement over the K850i model which failed in this
aspect. Let's compare to Samsung E840:
Let's compare to Sony Ericsson W580i:
Communications
Sony Ericsson W910i is designed to operate in GSM 850/900/1800/1900 and UMTS
850/1900/2100 frequency bands, it supports GPRS and EDGE. Similar to K850i
it¡s among the pioneer devices comprising 3G support and EDGE functionality.
For instance, the W85 had a special focus on it. Instead of HSCSD like in
K800i, HSDPA is supported. The W910i is deprived of an external antenna out
(in a most unexplainable manner ¡V all of the precursors had that socket)
The wireless communications of W910i include Bluetooth 2.0 and EDR. It works
quite all right, and also behaves nicely with the Bluetooth headset. We used
the bundled DS-200 one, it worked like a dream. Sony Ericsson products sport
the best A2DP implementation on the market. In addition to that, the
following profiles are supported:
Basic Imaging
Dial-up Networking
File Transfer
Generic Access
Generic Object Exchange
Handsfree
Headset
HID
JSR-82 Java API
Object Push
Personal Area Networking
Serial Port
Synchronization
SyncML OBEX binding
Audio/Video Remote Control
Phonebook Access
Bluetooth can now be used even in the Flight Mode which was out of the
questions in the earlier models.
The original trademark socket is used for plugging the cable ¡V the
manufacturer claims it¡s pure USB 2.0 but in fact it works like it weren¡t
anywhere near 2.0 ¡V the speed is much lower. Modem connection, Mass Storage
and PictBridge modes are supported, you can select the mode in the
appropriate menu. The Mass Storage connection worked quite all right for us,
both storage arrays were correctly detected and available for data exchange
¡V the user memory of the phone itself and the memory expansion card. The
Sony Ericssson PC Suite software allows for phone-to-PC synchronization, the
program comes on the bundled CD.
An integrated FM tuner with track recognition functionality comes in handy,
making use of the TrackID service. RDS is fully supported, up to 20 favorite
frequencies can be bookmarked. The application interface is neat and easy to
get along with. The signal quality stays on a irreproachable level. The
sound volume of the speaker and the wire headset is quite good yet not as
loud as in Nokia phones, while the Bluetooth headset is, on the other hand,
louder.
Memory
Sony Ericsson W910i offers some 35 Mb of ROM which is a very modest value
considering the musical orientation of the device, but a 1 Gb expansion card
of the M2 type comes with the sales package. An M2-USB card reader is
another accessory included in the price of the product that you will find
bundled with the handset ¡V this is the first time SE includes a thing like
that, must be another try at advertising the well-known Memory Stick (in
K850i that was combined with microSD). It¡s hardly believable that the
manufacturer will drop pushing forward their trademark stuff to let the
customer audience yield a breath of relief, - since SE spent too much money
and time into developing that kind of stuff, - but at least they are trying
to make these features more user friendly and usable ¡V for instance, the M2
capacity limit was raised to 4 GB for W910i so if you try to take maximum
advantage out of this memory stick business, at least you won¡t be faced
with any compatibility issues.
Display
Sony Ericsson W910i comes with a TFT-powered display with a QVGA resolution
of 320x240. It can display up to 262K colors, and the diagonal is as long as
2,2¡¡. The image in fact looks very appeasing ¡V it¡s all right about the
contrast, brightness and color depth, let alone the very good view angles
offering you a great liberty of glance ¡V you can try looking at the screen
from all imaginable spots and angles, in the majority of cases you do see
the actual picture without any glaring or fading which you might expect. The
mirror backing helps to do away with the nasty side effects when the screen
is exposed to direct sunlight.
User Interface
Along with K850i, the device in question became one of the first models
based off the A200 updated software platform. There aren¡t any revolutionary
changes, but a good deal of improvements won¡t leave you untouched:
Media Gallery
Walkman player 3.0 + DRM 2.0
Smart Search
Java Platform 8 (JP-8)
Increased phonebook capacity (5000)
New Browser (NetFront 3.4)
ActiveSync and MTP Support (Media Transfer Protocol)
A large number of minor improvements are just finishing touches over the
whole panorama of SonyEricsson product evolution ¡V the newer generation of
devices, while offering a better functionality, still respects the heritage
of the older platform. Nothing went upside down so SE fans can sleep
peacefully.
The user is offered a number of visual themes to choose from. Both stock and
custom wallpapers can be used for each individual theme, the screensaver is
also customizable ¡V any .swf animation would fit. During standby, the
screen is rich in information: the status line at the top of the screen
displays icons indicating the signal level, battery charge, message and call
notices, Bluetooth activation status and so on. The size of the screen clock
is also customizable, there¡s an appropriate menu item on the screen
settings tab.
The main menu looks in the traditional way of most SE products: a total of
four rows of bright, neat looking animated icons which can be optionally
replaced with a fascinating flash-theme with a lot of customizable aspects
including the icon order, size, animation, color and so on. Moving the
selection from one icon to another is accompanied with a slight vibration if
the selected them has this feature turned on. Five themes come preinstalled
on the device. The twelve icons make up the main menu:
PlayNow
Internet
Entertainment
Camera
Messaging
Media
Radio
Contacts
Walkman
Calls
Organizer
Settings
The menu can be navigated through by pressing the numeric buttons in a
desired sequence, each key corresponding to a menu item with the same number
that should be activated. Besides the vertically arranged menu items, some
menus contain horizontal sub-tabs, e.g. the File manager of Call log menus,
such tabs can be opened or minimized by pressing the navigation button left
or right.
The menu enjoys a sound implementation, the only drawback being the lack of
an option to customize the order in which the menu items follow ¡V Nokia and
Motorola have been offering such functionality for quite a while by now. For
instance, there ¡s the PlayNow 4.0 service icon, giving quick access to
games, Ringtones and music catalogues by Sony BMG. This feature is scarcely
handy in everyday usage, and most users would gladly replace it with
something more close to life, e.g. a profiles menu shortcut or something of
the kind but not with this model, alas!
There ¡s also a quick menu with four tabs:
New Events
Running apps
My shortcuts
Internet
The first one lists all the events: reminders, calls and messages. The
second one shows the list of currently running applications, in fact it¡s a
task manager that allows switching between currently running Java tasks.
This, for instance, allows playing your favorite game and talking to people
over ICQ at the same time with no need to interrupt either process. This
feature is one of the cornerstones of the platform. The third tab of the
quick menu stores user shortcuts. The fourth is for keeping bookmarks and
links to frequently used resources.
Call Service
The phonebook can store up to 5000 records (in contrary to the old value of
1000), up to 7 numbers associated with each record (the number was five in
earlier models), namely being home number, three types of mobile numbers ¡V
common, personal and work, the work number, fax and a misc number. Upon
adding a new number to an existing record the user is asked to specify the
type of the number, duplicate types are not allowed ¡V only one number per
type is the rule, e.g. you can¡t store three home numbers or two work
numbers associated assigned to the same phonebook record. You don¡t to open
a record each time you want to list all the numbers since you can browse
through them by pressing the navigation button sideways right in the contact
list. Any of the numbers associated with a contact record can be selected as
the default one (it will be automatically dialed, if not purposely specified
otherwise, each time you call that person).
Miscellaneous field of a phonebook record include e-mail address, IM number,
Web address, regular mail address, work position, company, home and work
addresses and the date of birth, which is synchronized with the
corresponding calendar event.
Contact records can be distributed between various user groups however you
can¡t distinguish a group by giving it a unique icon or ringtone ¡V which
for sure is a sad thing. Though that doesn¡t keep you from giving unique
ringtone and icon to each individual record ¡V you can even select one of
your voice records for that.
The contact list is split between the people whose records are stored in the
phone memory and those unlucky outcasts who happened to reside on the SIM
card ¡V the thing is that in full accordance with the weird SE tradition you
can¡t put the both kinds on the same list ¡V the only option that is left to
the user is switching between the phone and SIM contact lists. Also you can
specify which one will be used as the default phonebook. You can also check
an option that would automatically save all the new phonebook records to the
SIM card, not quite sure what¡s the trick here and why one would want to use
the SIM card as their primary phonebook. But the most important option is
the one that makes a backup of the whole contact book and writes it to the
memory expansion card. Unfortunately, SonyEricsson didn¡t provide us with
any blacklisting functionality (e.g. similar to the Samsung blacklisting
option) so you either have to drop unwanted calls or look for a 3rd party
Java application that would add blacklisting to the rest of vanilla
features. You can only sort records either by first name or by last name,
there¡s no option to use other fields as search criteria.
Smart Search is a phone number filter that pretends to be smart. If you
begin typing a number in standby, the phone reacts by displaying a pop-up
with all the numbers beginning with the initial digits you just typed put on
a list to pick the one whom you want to call or send a message. The system
is practically identical with the same stuff found with Samsung and WM-based
phones.
The number of voice marks you can leave for further usage with the voice
dial option is limited to 40 ¡V that¡s an outdated system they¡re using, no
changes can be traced from the days of T610i, we wouldn¡t say it¡s too
comfortable (well, telling the truth, it in fact isn¡t). Motorola phones for
instance sport a much better realization of this feature.
PhotoID and VideoID services are well-implemented, the image used as the
call icon is large enough. The font in which the phone numbers are displayed
during dialup is big enough to see from a distance. Numeric keys from 2 to 9
can be used as quick dial shortcuts, the only thing you need is to associate
a phone number with a particular keypad button.
The call log shares a common SE design ¡V received, dialed and missed calls
are shown on the same list, each call type distinguished with a
corresponding icon, but you can also switch between separate logs for each
specific call type by pressing the navigation button left and right.
Messaging
Sony Ericsson are known for the efficiency of the messaging system they¡re
putting in their phones ¡V up to 1000 SMS can be stored in the user memory
(plus the SIM card SMS storage), the MMS service also enjoys on the best
implementations ever. Besides you can read RSS feeds, just specify the
address and title of the feed and you¡re done, no specific settings are
required for that. Messages can be categorized, but seemingly no other
differences from the traditional messaging system widely found with other SE
devices. Upon creating a new message the user is prompted to select one of
the following types: Text message, Picture message, Voice message or E-mail.
A fast symbol line prompts when to expect the needed symbol while you¡re
typing - s very helpful aid to those who seldom compose messages. The
maximum message length is limited to 1900, up to eight lines of text fall
into the field of view simultaneously. The Copy & Paste function is a very
helpful addition that allows either for the whole text or for selected
fragments of it to be copied. Besides a limited number of Nokia models, no
analogous functionality is known to exist on the market. The function can be
called through the context menu, then you have to mark the beginning and the
ending of the fragment you want to select. Additional messaging features
include T9 input, emoticons, chat support.
You can select one of the 7 stock signals for the incoming message sound or
choose a custom audio file. Options include the so-called ¡¥reading notice¡
¡V if activated, the recipient of the message will be asked for a
acknowledgement that the message was read that he can confirm ¡V it really
makes sense for messages of extreme urgency when it¡s vital to know that the
message was read by the recipient.
The E-Mail client is not bad yet it could use a little bit more
functionality. Attachments are supported, they can be saved to ROM no matter
if it can be correctly recognized by the application. There¡s no support for
viewing Office files. E-mail messages can be sorted by size, date and time
or by the content of the message itself. Three font sizes are available for
the messages: small, medium and large. The message can be displayed in
fullscreen mode, the copy/paste functionality is supported.
The following coding tables are supported:
ISO: ISO-8859-1, ISO-8859-2, ISO-8859-5, ISO-8859-7, ISO-8859-9.ISO-8859-10
Windows: Windows-1251, Windows-1252, Windows-1254, Windows-1255,
Windows-1258
US-ASCII
Unicode: UTF-7, UTF-8, UTF-16
Japanese: Shift.JIS, ISO-2022-JP
Cyrillic: KOI8-R
Simplified Chinese: GB2312, GB18030
Traditional Chinese: Big5
Thai TIS - 60
Thanks to the updated A200 platform and its enhanced multimedia support, all
the latest SE devices have a fine set of MMS features. You use multimedia
files as attachments, choosing a file from File Manager, Contacts, Calendar,
Task, Note, Browser (vBookmark) or right from the camera. The following
formats are supported:
Audio:
AAC, AMR, MPEG Layer 3, Real 8, AWB, WAV, MP4, MIDI, iMelody, 3GPP, XMF,
M4A, RHZ, WMA
Video: MPG4, 3GPP, SDP, Real8, WMV
graphics: JPEG, GIF87, GIF89A, PNG, SVG, WBMP, BMP
As we see, the list is quite impressive for a non-smartphone device. The
image attachment can either keep the original size or be resized to one of
the following resolutions: 640x480, 320x240 or 120x160. Message options
include message auto-loading, delivery and reading notices, message
composition mode (where you select from strict size limit / size warning if
exceeds)
PIM
The calendar can be viewed by month or by week, the latter case features
daily and hourly scheduling, a quick jump to a specified year, month or day
is always possible. Each reminder can be given a specific type, duration,
location and a preliminary notice. If the appropriate option is activated,
the reminders will work even while the phone is turned off. A full-blown
support is given to recurring and expiring events (older than a day or a
weak), also there¡s the very handy search function for looking things up in
notices, reminders and other events.
Each day can be associated with a meeting (you need to specify a subject,
the start and end times, the interval of repetition at which the reminder
will occur and a general description). The tasklist has a very modest
realization: either the task label or the phone call label, just these two
event types to select from.
The birthday field found with every contact in your phonebook is
synchronized with the PIM so you won¡t miss your grandma¡s birthday ¡V you
will be warned beforehand so you get a good chance of coming in time and
with a gorgeous present. (Please don¡ t think I¡m so keen on grannies ¡V you
see, the guy who writes the original Russian articles is fond of ugly
language stamps and awkward phrases, and this grandmother business mentioned
every time when it comes to the PIM and the calendar has gotten on my nerves
just as much as on yours, - you are sure to have read the same rubbish in
the reviews for several times before, so please be prepared for seeing the
same hackneyed grandmother tale for a thousand more times, sorry messieurs
and mesdames - I can¡t be bothered with rewriting articles from scratch
since in essence I¡m a translator and not a journalist, and besides I want
you all to witness the fact that being a huge cell phone expert doesn¡t mean
having a huge talent in the way of belles-lettres; I¡m sick and tired of
wading through miles of poorly composed Russian text trying to give to all
this rant a more or less human face before rendering it into English, maybe
some day they¡ll hire a professional journalist to help our hardware experts
out since the experts¡ native Russian sucks up to the point where the very
crappy essence of its lameness manages to make it even into the English
translations no matter how hard I¡m trying to filter stuff, be it known to
you that you were all overly blessed by not being able to read the original
Russian texts which feel like a mixture of cheap trailer trash phrases and
cold war rhetoric, mind the hammer btw lolz - Neurotically yours, the
translator guy)
The alarm clock can be set either to be activated once or following a preset
weekly schedule, that¡s just more than enough. Any song can be set as the
signal.
Notes, timer, stopwatch and calculator ¡V all this stuff is quite standard,
the only interesting thing here is the simple yet handy password manager.
You¡re right to guess that its used for storing all kinds of user passwords.
Multimedia
The products of Sony-Ericsson Company are traditionally not bad in this
sphere, especially in terms of format compatibility. The phone supports MP4
(AAC, AAC+, eAAC+), MP3 (officially it supports bitrates up to 192kbit/sec,
but in our tests the device was able to handle even higher bitrates), MP4,
3GP (video: MPEG4 or H.263, H.264; sound: 3gp, AAC or AMR) , RealVideo 8,
WMV, ASF; graphics: JPEG, GIF, BMP, PNG, SVG, WBMP. In other words, it
supports all popular formats.
Let¡s start with the Media graphics viewer. As a matter of fact it is just a
viewer, but a very peculiar one - with an interface like Sony PSP and a
motion sensor which changes the display orientation. To judge the latter,
it¡s all solely up to the person¡s liking, to put it mildly, because some
would find it comfortable and the others surely wouldn¡t. As for the shake
controls, it supports the left turn only, if the phone rotates to the right
or turns upside down, nothing happens. But should you happen, for instance,
to browse through the gallery lying on the left side, the phone would change
the screen orientation automatically without any action required from the
user. If this feature annoys you, you can always switch it off.
Sony Ericsson weren¡t the first developers who had committed a fault
implementing this option. One of the latest solutions at last free of the
issue is a Samsung handset, whose older relatives suffered from the same
quirk. Besides controlling the screen orientation, this feature is only used
in a few applications like the MarbleMadness game. Getting back to the media
gallery options, let¡s see what functions are available to the user. The
menu items are: Photo, Music, Video, TV, Settings. The functionality of each
is described below:
Photo. It is a key point of the new Cyber-shot flagship, which lets you
browse your photo gallery in the thumbnail mode and view selected picture,
it also has a sorting feature and grants access to subfolders. It also has a
slide-show feature and the whole functionality of the gallery application
appears to be better, for instance, than Samsung G600, but on the other hand
in Nokia N95 the gallery still has more features.
Music. Grants access to audio content where you can sort songs by performer,
album, track name, etc. The audio player application itself is sufficient
for all the basic needs but little else. We¡ll give it a detailed
examination a little bit further in the article.
Video This is a video player, video clips catalogue and subcasts.
TV. This is digital television, which is currently not in a high demand
because the device doesn¡t support Wi-Fi. Waiting for 3G¡K
Settings. Miscellaneous settings so far include only one category ¡V the
motion sensor. It is possible to configure portrait or landscape settings
manually or activate auto-rotation.
The Walkman player was updated to v3. The navigation went through some
changes, DRM 2.0 support appeared along with some other minor updates. For
example, Digital Right Manager (DRM) is used to describe technologies, which
provide music access control. Is it really so important?
Some time ago Open Mobile Alliance organization prepared a packet of
research documents describing methods of digital content distribution,
interaction protocols for mobile phones and other DRM devices. OMA DRM
standard provides the ability to control mobile content usage. This occurs
by means of adding special copyright signatures to the distributed content.
The signatures define the end user usage policy, which may include time
limits or a fixed number of launches, and other kinds of protection .
Different combinations of these parameters are also available.
What does the second revision of the platform bring on? Back in 2001,
methods like Forward Lock, Combined Delivery, Separate Delivery were on the
OMA DRM 1.0 specifications list. In comparison with it, the newer
specifications also define a set of functional extensions, such as Domains,
combined object rights etc. ¡V something like logical continuation, but
nothing else. The player controls are very comfortable, settings like track
repeat, play random, sorting by performer, genre, extended stereo (but this
option really does not affect the sound quality) are included. There is also
the progressive track rewinding. The info on the currently playing song is
on the phone screen.
The controls are very comfortable, settings include repeat, reshuffle,
random song autoselect, sorting by performer, genre and extended stereo
(though the latter option has almost no perceptible effect on the quality of
sound). Progressive rewind is quite expectedly supported. The current song
info tab has an eye catching, nice design.
The lack of player skins looks rather lame in comparison with Nokia products
of the latest generation. The built-in shake control function provides you
to control the player through shaking the device. The function dubbed
¡§SensMe¡¨ allows you to choose the music according to your current mood.
Now you can search the compositions and make playlist based on music style
and tempo, not only by album or artist, as it used to be. Unique
visualization effects allow you to display the tracks as matrix bitmaps,
lying closer of farther from horizontal and vertical axes, symbolizing the
song genre. So you can compose a playlist perfectly corresponding to your
mood. Not a bad replacement for the ordinary sorting function.
The headsets included in the sales package sport a high quality yet lack
extended playback controls. The sound volume is sufficient for most
environments yet it¡s lower in comparison with the competing solutions. The
sound quality is quite good, it can even beat the latest Nokia phones and
almost reaches Samsung models.
The TrackID service is fully operational. With it¡s help you can record a
part of a composition, then it is sent to the web. The information about the
song title and performer name, if available, is forwarded to you in a
message. This also means that the track is in the database and, of course,
you can purchase it immediately. The service could be interesting to a large
number of users, mostly the youth. This feature is also useful with an FM
tuner.
The integrated editors include PhotoDJ for handling images, the VideoDJ and
MusicDJ respectively deal with video and music. The photo editor allows for
all the basic imaging functions:
Rotate
Auto levels
Brightness
Auto light balance
Contrast
Remove Red Eye
Apply Effect (Negative, Cartoon, Frosted glass, Painting)
Add Item (Frame, Clipart, Text)
The other two are less interesting, the edition of music tracks in midi
format, the creation of short video clips with standard effects. The need is
nominal.
The voice recorder allows to record phone talks as well, but you have to go
to the appropriate menu to turn it on. The record length is only limited by
the remaining memory space.
Preinstalled software
Besides multimedia applications, as we have already mentioned, the phone
also has a set of pre-installed software, such as NetFront browser
supporting SmartFit technology, which can show you standard pages in a
single column. There are also an option for saving pictures from the web to
the phone, landscape mode display, page zoom. But for those who are keen on
Internet, OperaMini remains the best choice.
Java implementation is simply brilliant:
Java 2, Micro Edition (J2ME)
CLDC1.1(JSR139)
MIDP2.0(JSR118)
Wireless Messaging API (JSR 120/205)
Mobile Media API (JSR 135)
Java Technology for the Wireless Industry (JSR 185)
Java API for Bluetooth (JSR 82)
PDA Optional Packages for J2ME? Platform (JSR 75)
Web Services (JSR 172)
Advanced Multimedia Supplements API (Cam?era Capabilities of JSR-234)
Java 3D
Mascot Capsule Micro3D Version 3
Mobile 3D Graphics API for J2ME (JSR 184)
Java Platform 8 (JP-8)
Java Platform 8 (JP8) is especially remarkable. W910i (on the same level
with the other A200-based novelties) had become the first mobile phone with
a functionality like this. Putting aside the details, this instrument is a
programmer ¡s paradise because it provides instant messaging and chats,
money transactions and safe identification and much more.
Java performance will be examined later.
Among the pre-installed games we would like to mention the well-made Tennis
Multiplay ¡V a classic sports entertainment with 3D graphics. Also there is
Marble Madness 3D, which makes use of the motion sensor. The remote control
application allows to operate a remote PC provided that it has a special
program installed on it; that program is included in the software CD that
comes with the phone. The last two memorable things are FaceWarp and HP
Print.
A quite simple file manager with basic functionality is also provided. And
there, in contrast with the contacts book, it is possible to show the
content from user memory and memory expansion card either separately or on a
single list.
Installing new software takes almost no time and never brings any trouble,
sending the jar file via Bluetooth is the only thing you need to install an
application. Similar to other devices by this manufacturer, you can run
several Java applications simultaneously. The performance of the Java
virtual machine is enough even for a large number of applications run at the
same time. An active application can be minimized without interrupting the
process. The list of currently running applications is shown on the
corresponding tab of the Activity menu. Applications can be closed, switched
between, everything is user-friendly to the limit.
Settings
Traditionally there are five tab pages with settings:
General
Sounds & alerts
Display
Calls
Connectivity
On the first tab you can select the profile (Normal, Meeting, In car,
Outdoors, Handsfree, Home, Office), but you cannot create a new profile,
though customizing an existing profile is allowed.
Date/Time adjustment, language selection is done in the same menu; update
service voice control settings are held at the same place. To dial a number
using only your voice you would have to record your own marks, there is no
functionality like in the latest generation of Nokia or Motorola phones. You
can also answer a call with your voice, listen to the name of the caller,
set the so-called ¡§magic word¡¨ ¡V a voice command enabling voice control
when an accessory like handsfree or automobile speakerphone is connected.
The way you are given notices is also customizable: a pop-up window or a
reminder on the Events list.
The ¡§flight mode¡¨ option is available but this model is still unable to
work without a SIM card, which is a major drawback in comparison with
competitive products by Nokia.
On the second tab you can choose the ringtone and set the volume, activate
the XXX ring, vibration, set up keyboard sounds, light effects etc.
On the third tab you it is possible to select a theme or a custom wallpaper,
the welcome message, the screensaver, its brightness (default 100%), screen
clock size (small or large)
On the fourth all call stats functions (Speed dial, Time & cost, Show/hide
my no.), and Smart Search are list.
The last tab allows you to configure Bluetooth and USB, synchronization,
Internet access, data transfer modes, etc.
Camera
The camera is a typical mid-end solution, but for the price of W910i it is
quite a poor offering ¡V an inexpensive 2 Mpix module with no autofocus.
Camera is located at the top edge of the slider; it is exposed to physical
damage, scratching and dust even while the slider is closed. The flashlight
and the self-portrait mirror are not included, though neither was the model
recommended as a camera phone.
The photos are taken in the landscape orientation. The maximum resolution is
1600x1200 for photos and 176x144 (15 fps) for video. So the video quality is
just low as it sounds. The interface is quite all right. The best thing
about the gallery is that clip thumbnails are not static, they start playing
when selected. Playback is well done, the best resolution for watching
videos is 320x240 pixels, the standard framerate is 30 fps.
Zoom is done by pressing the sound volume button, to control brightness you
have to use the horizontal extremities of the navigation button. During the
photo mode the display is moderately informative: there is a frame counter,
the shooting mode switch, a number of preferences and settings along with
the return function, and also the folder where the photos are saved.
Switching between photo and video is done by pressing the navigation button
right or left.
Sony Ericsson W910i Photo Settings:
Shoot modes Normal, Panorama, Frames, Burst
Picture size 2 MP (1600x1200)
1 MP (1280x960)
VGA (640x480)
Night Mode On, Off
Self-timer On, Off
Effects Off, Black & white, Negative, Sepia
White balance Auto, Daylight, Cloudy, Fluorescent, Incandescent
Picture quality Normal, Fine
Shutter sounds On, Off
Turn on time and date Adds a timestamp to the image
Save to user memory, memory expansion card
Sony Ericsson W910i Camera settings:
Video size QCIF (176x144)
Shoot modes For picture message, High quality video
Night Mode On, Off
Effects Off, Black & white, Negative, Sepia
White balance Auto, Daylight, Cloudy, Fluorescent, Incandescent
Turn on/off microphone Yes
Save to memory user memory, memory expansion card
Image quality is somewhere a bit below the middle judging by the modern
standards. More or less comprehensible photos can be achieved only with an
ideal light setting, in the rest of the cases the pictures taken with this
phone look in a way disappointing. It ¡s more than evident that camera is
not the priority.
There are two picture resolutions available for video calls: QCIF (176X144)
and SQCIF (128X96). Zoom, as it used to be, is 2x digital (3x for the main
camera). The brightness is adjustable, but the white balance has only a
single setting, ¡§auto¡¨. There is also a nighttime mode available.
Performance
As usual, the Java implementation is on a high level. W910i supports 3D
profiles and sending midlets via Bluetooth.
Jbenchmark 1.0.1 Score 7222
Text 1964
2D Shapes 1983
3D Shapes 873
Fill Rate 667
Animation 1735
Jbenchmark 2.0.1 Score 978
Image Manipulations 321
Text 657
Sprites 505
3D Transform 662
User Interface 12617
Jbenchmark 3D HQ 371
Jbenchmark 3D LQ 424
Triangles ps 30619
KTexels ps 1517
Jbenchmark HD Gaming Score 151 (5.0 fps)
Smooth triangles 28641
Textured triangles 24299
Fill rate, KTexels 1972
The device has passed all the tests successfully.
Market perspectives
The new flagship model from the Walkman series appears to be in many ways
interesting, but seriously overrated. Of course, we took full consideration
of the rich sales package and the unique specifications. But even with all
this stuff on hands, the device is grossly overpriced. As expected, W910i
will begin selling by the end of October. The closest possible (and by the
way, significantly more successful) replacement claiming the same niche as
part of its market coverage is Nokia N81, which is going to in November ¡V
by the time when Sony Ericsson is candidate will be available in full supply
worldwide. Let ¡s guess:
SonyEricsson W910i Nokia N81
Dimensions: 99.5 x 50 x 12.5 mm 102 x 50 x 17.9 mm
Weight: 86 g 140 g
Storage: 35 Mb + M2 (1 Gb) 12 Mb + microSD (2 Gb)
Display: 2,4¡¨ , QVGA, 262K 2,4¡¨ , QVGA, 16M
Wireless protocols: Bluetooth 2.0 Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 2.0
Camera: 2 Mpix, no autofocus 2 Mpix, no autofocus
EDGE: + +
FM-tuner: + +
Battery: 930 mAh 1050 mAh
As we can see, the Finnish try at making a music slider proved more
successful and less expensive. Don ¡t forget that this is a fully functional
Symbian smartphone based off the S60 platform, while W910i is just an
ordinary mobile phone. N81 also possesses powerful a powerful gaming
component, it fully supports the new N-Gage gaming technology, includes a
larger memory card in the sales package, and offers a full Wi-Fi support.
Finally there is the beefed up, slightly more expensive version with 8 Gb of
user memory (but lacking the memory expansion slot) W910i just has a thinner
body and there ¡s nothing more on the advantage list. Enhancements like
Shake Control and SenseMe, and the quality Bluetooth headset make this
device advantageous in a way but still it ¡s a controversial niche product
oriented only at a certain part of the music-listening audience. The Nokia
solution covers a larger audience and thus is more successful and profitable
for its creators. The market success of Nokia N81 is also owed to a lower
price which is the most vital criteria for the consumer majority, and the
difference from W910i is quite great ¡V obviously, to the better side. A
serious rival quite capable of challenging the both will be officially
announced soon - Samsung F330. Look forward to the upcoming review devoted
to the Korean novelty.
opinion
Sony Ericsson W910i, upon a second glance at the price label, is quite a
disputable offering, which will be fully suitable only for the brand ¡s most
devoted fans. The specialty of the new phone, - in other words the part
which deals with the music, - sports a high functionality, but hardly
anything else in this model deserves the same words. It clearly needs a 3.5
mm jack, some dedicated player controls and a higher sound volume. Besides
this, the shake control and SenseMe features look interesting but don ¡t
help the cause much, and won ¡t be needed by the majority. Track ID is just
a complementary feature as well and does not matter as much as Sony Ericsson
would think themselves. At last, the Bluetooth headset is very useful, but
is ¡t that much of an innovation since this kind of accessories can be
purchased separately at a very acceptable price of about £á50. All in all,
the W910i model is ¡t a revolution on the market of music phones.
Looking outside the music sphere, the device has a rather plain set of
features. A 2 mpx camera without auto focusing looks archaic placed in a
model from the top price range, the M2 expansion slot is ¡t as practical as
you ¡d wish even considering the bundled card reader. Traditionally the
software platform is what makes a phone popular, and now it is even more
functional than before. The user interface of this model is really one of
the most successful solutions available on the market, but when it comes to
the music player, the latest Nokia phones based off S40 5th revision have a
richer functionality, e.g. the option to switch player skins. W910i is jack
of all trades but master of none, - well, save for the music maybe but still
it makes no heroic deeds on this field as well, - pick it only if you Are
looking for a music phone with lots of extras from all the imaginable
spheres ¡K yet no matter how hard it tried, the model would not make a
decent smart phone ¡V save for the price, maybe.
Go Back
to Page 1 |